Intellectual Property-Copyright: The Challenges and Changes

Intellectual Property-Copyright: The Challenges and Changes


In the modern digital age, the concept of intellectual property (IP) copyright has become increasingly significant, not only for creators and artists but also for the general public and legal entities. This article looks at the essence of IP copyright, a legal mechanism designed to protect the original work of creators from unauthorised use, ensuring that their creative contributions are recognised and rewarded. It explores the evolution of laws crafted to safeguard these intellectual rights. Historically, legislation such as the Berne Convention and various national laws have been established, offering a legal framework for the protection of artistic and intellectual creations.

Understanding how these laws are enforced is crucial in comprehending the full scope of IP copyright. Enforcement mechanisms vary globally, involving judicial systems, custom authorities, and digital monitoring tools, balancing the rights of creators with public access. The concept of ‘Fair Use’ is a further critical aspect of copyright law that allows limited use of copyrighted material without permission under certain conditions. Determining what constitutes fair use involves assessing factors such as the purpose of use, nature of the copyrighted work, the amount used in relation to the whole work, and the effect of use on the market value of the original work. It adds significantly to the complexity of decision making in this already complicated environment.

A Changing World

In an era marked by rapid technological advancements and globalisation, intellectual property (IP) copyright now faces at least four new, unprecedented challenges. The onset of digital technology has significantly altered the landscape of copyright enforcement and compliance, raising complex questions about the control and distribution of digital works. Additionally, the global differences in copyright law create a patchwork of varying standards that affect the dissemination and protection of international works, challenging creators and businesses alike. Furthermore, the interaction of copyright laws with other forms of intellectual property protection, such as patents and trademarks, adds layers of complexity to legal rights and enforcement. Finally, recent legal and legislative developments continue to reshape the boundaries and application of copyright law, responding to evolving technological realities and cultural shifts. This dynamic environment presents both challenges and opportunities for stakeholders in the realm of IP copyright, making it a subject of keen interest and critical importance.

1. Going Digital

Digital technology has revolutionised the landscape of copyright enforcement and compliance. The ease of copying and distributing digital content has led to a surge in copyright infringement cases, making it increasingly difficult for copyright owners to monitor and protect their works. This proliferation of digital content has also necessitated the development of sophisticated tools and technologies for monitoring and enforcement, such as digital watermarking and online tracking systems. Simultaneously, digital technology has facilitated new methods for creators to disseminate and monetise their works, such as digital rights management (DRM) systems. These technologies allow creators to control the distribution and usage of their content, providing a mechanism to enforce their rights in the digital realm.

However, the application of these technologies is not without controversy. DRM, for instance, has raised concerns regarding user rights and fair access to digital content. Moreover, the vast and decentralised nature of the internet poses significant challenges to effective enforcement, often requiring international cooperation and cross-border legal frameworks. The impact of digital technology on copyright enforcement and compliance is a rapidly evolving area, with continuous developments in legal, technological and societal domains. It underscores the need for adaptive and balanced approaches to protect copyright while fostering innovation and access to digital content.

2. Global Scope

The international nature of copyright adds multifaceted challenges to its enforcement and compliance. One primary issue is the variance in copyright laws across different countries. While international agreements like the Berne Convention aim to provide a basic standard, the extent and manner of copyright protection can vary significantly from one jurisdiction to another. This disparity creates a complex legal landscape for creators and distributors, especially for those whose works cross international borders.

Another challenge is the enforcement of rights in a global digital environment. The internet’s borderless nature means that copyrighted content can be easily accessed and distributed worldwide, often in jurisdictions with differing legal frameworks and enforcement capabilities. This makes it difficult to pursue legal remedies against infringement occurring outside an author’s home country.

Moreover, the cultural and economic differences influencing copyright perceptions and practices add another layer of complexity. For instance, what is considered fair use or a common practice in one region may be viewed as infringement in another.

These challenges necessitate international cooperation and harmonisation of laws to effectively protect copyright in the global context. However, achieving this is an intricate process, given the diverse interests and legal systems involved.

3. Adding Complexity

Copyright laws interact with other forms of intellectual property (IP) protection, such as patents and trademarks, in multifaceted ways, each covering different aspects of creativity and innovation. Patents protect inventions and functional aspects of products, offering a monopoly over the manufacture, use and sale of the invention for a limited period. Copyrights, conversely, protect original works of authorship, including literary, dramatic, musical, and artistic works, but do not cover the functional aspects.

Trademarks protect symbols, names and slogans used to identify goods or services. While trademarks safeguard brand identity, copyright protects the expression of ideas, not the ideas themselves. There’s a potential overlap when a copyrighted work becomes distinctive enough to function as a brand identifier, thus warranting trademark protection.

Design rights, another IP form, protect the appearance of a product, including shape, colour and texture. They often intersect with copyright when the design element is also an artistic work. In such cases, the same object might be protected simultaneously by both rights, albeit for different aspects.

Understanding these interactions is crucial for effectively navigating the IP landscape, as they can complement each other to provide broader protection. However, it also requires careful navigation to avoid conflicts and ensure the appropriate application of each right.

4. Keeping pace

Recent legal and legislative developments in copyright law reflect the ongoing effort to adapt to the digital era’s challenges and the globalised nature of content creation and distribution. One significant advancement has been the implementation of the Digital Single Market Strategy by the European Union, aiming to modernise copyright laws for the digital age. This includes directives that address the use of copyrighted material on online platforms and ensure fair remuneration for creators.

In the United States, the Music Modernization Act, passed in 2018, represents a major overhaul in music licensing laws. It simplifies the process of licensing music rights, establishes a public database for music copyright information, and ensures that songwriters and artists receive royalties from digital streaming services.

Globally, there’s a trend towards strengthening the protection of digital rights. Countries are revising their copyright laws to better address issues like digital piracy and the use of copyrighted materials in user-generated content on social media platforms. These legislative changes underscore the need for copyright laws to keep pace with technological advancements and changing consumption patterns, balancing the interests of creators, consumers and distributors in the digital age.

As we navigate the evolving landscape of intellectual property copyright, the challenges ahead are marked by rapid technological advancements and globalisation. Balancing the protection of creators’ rights with public access and adapting to diverse legal frameworks remain critical. Continuous dialogue and collaborative international efforts will be pivotal in shaping effective and equitable copyright policies.


Celebrate 9 Years with EIMF

EIMF Has Assisted 6,000+ Professionals Get Certified


Ready for your next professional certification? Choose from 9 self-paced eLearning courses and enjoy a 30% discount!

*complete your purchase before 21 April 2024

Starts 20 February 2024

Master in Governance,
Risk & Compliance

Accredited by the CyQAA, our GRC programme empowers you to navigate complex regulations, manage risks, and fortify governance structures. Dive into a dynamic learning experience that ensures ethical operations, regulatory compliance, and risk reduction.

✅ Explore Scholarships & Financial Aid ✅ Discover the Match Funding Scheme